Re: [rdo-dev] [all] Revisiting RDO Technical Definition of Done
On Wed, Nov 29, 2017 at 9:32 AM, Haïkel <hguemar(a)fedoraproject.org> wrote:
> - CI promotion GA criteria is changed from Jenkins pipeline to
the
> list of jobs running with RPM packages directly, initial set would be
> all weirdo jobs running in [3]
I'd like to ensure that TripleO CI is still monitored closely during
the development cycle.
So it can be a non-blocking criteria for GA.
As Javier noticed it means that our jobs will be based upon POI and
packstack. It should encourage
us to work with other installers supporting "raw" packages to make
sure that we will be able to test our
artefacts long-term.
> - TripleO jobs would not be part of RDO GA criteria since TripelO now
> requires containers which RDO will not ship.TripleO promotion CI will
> continue running with containers built with RDO Trunk packages.
>
Question is to know if upstream is okay with shipping containers images
using
our trunk packages. Otherwise ack.
All deployment projects are cycle-trailing [1] which means OpenStack cuts a
release on day 0 and projects such as TripleO,
Kolla,
Packstack and
Puppet-OpenStack can lag behind quite a bit
, sometimes more than a week.
This puts us in a very odd chicken-and-egg scenario where the deployment
projects aren't ready but we are.
RDO's job is to package and ship the signed tarballs as delivered by the
OpenStack release.
Whether or not TripleO, Packstack or Puppet-OpenStack works with the release
packages is pretty unlikely to be because of problems with RDO *packages*.
The content of the tarballs isn't going to change. If we end up finding a
legit
bug in the packaging (spec files, mirrors, etc.), these can be hotfixed
easily.
IMO, when comes release time, installers should be used to sanity check the
*repositories* to ensure there are no missing packages, that the packages
are
at the right versions, etc. They've actually been quite helpful with that
in the
past.
If there are installer bugs, I would not block the release of RDO.
[1]:
https://releases.openstack.org/reference/release_models.html#cycle-trailing
David Moreau Simard
Senior Software Engineer | OpenStack RDO
dmsimard = [irc, github, twitter]
Attachments:
- attachment.html (text/html — 4.1 KB)